Diddy's Defense Team Claims Cassie & The Mogul Were Both Abusive To Each Other

BY Gabriel Bras Nevares 2.2K Views
Link Copied to Clipboard!
Diddy Defense Team Cassie Both Abusive Hip Hop News
May 2, 2015; Las Vegas, NV, USA; Recording artist Sean Combs aka P Diddy in attendance during the world welterweight championship bout between Floyd Mayweather and Manny Pacquiao at MGM Grand Garden Arena. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports via Imagn Images
Diddy's lawyers previously attempted to exclude the footage of him attacking Cassie from his federal trial.

The Diddy trial kicked off this week, and his relationship with Cassie continues to be one of the most contentious parts of the whole process. Her allegations kicked this scandal off, but now the defense argues the story is not exactly what it seems.

Per TMZ, prosecutor Emily Anne Johnson and defense attorney Marc Agnifilo had a discussion on day four of the trial. In a New York City federal courtroom with Judge Arun Subramanian, they discussed Sean Combs and his bond with Cassie Ventura. The Bad Boy mogul's defense claims she was also abusive in their relationship.

The debate began when prosecutor Johnson stated that Victim-1, presumably the singer, will not face cross-examination on particular medical problems. Judge Subramanian reportedly said the defense can eventually cross-examine if the prosecution removes this limitation.

In response, Marc Agnifilo revealed the defense team "is going to take the position there was mutual violence in their relationship... hitting, on both sides: DV (domestic violence)." He added: "We are absolutely going to admit to domestic violence. But at what point does it become coercive?"

Then, the judge reportedly asked Agnifilo if he means Diddy and Cassie's relationship was outright violent. "Right. We're saying it's relevant," the defense attorney reportedly replied.

What Is Diddy's Net Worth?

MLS: Leagues Cup-Atlanta United FC at Inter Miami CF
Jul 25, 2023; Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA; Recording artist Sean Combs attends the game between the Atlanta United and the Inter Miami CF at DRV PNK Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Sam Navarro-USA TODAY Sports via Imagn Images

On the other hand, prosecutor Johnson announced she would submit a letter to the court about this matter. This is because of her plans to present two cellphone videos and corrected footage of the 2016 hotel assault which shocked the world a year ago. Since this scandal blew up, Puff's net worth has reportedly sank from a billion to around $400 million.

Speaking of which, Diddy's team wants to exclude this Cassie footage from the trial. While they failed in excluding other alleged evidence from this procedure, it's unclear if the CNN video is still on the table. Given Johnson's comments, it seems like prosecutors are still counting on its introduction and discussion.

Elsewhere in this legal whirlwind, Diddy's alleged victims are supposedly reconsidering their testimony. However, other aspects of the trial tipped more in favor of the prosecution's proposals. So there are no big wins or losses so far, just complex and difficult decisions and debates. We will see if Combs and Cassie's relationship continues to fall under the microscope.

About The Author
Gabriel Bras Nevares is a staff writer for HotNewHipHop. He joined HNHH while completing his B.A. in Journalism & Mass Communication at The George Washington University in the summer of 2022. Born and raised in San Juan, Puerto Rico, Gabriel treasures the crossover between his native reggaetón and hip-hop news coverage, such as his review for Bad Bunny’s hometown concert in 2024. But more specifically, he digs for the deeper side of hip-hop conversations, whether that’s the “death” of the genre in 2023, the lyrical and parasocial intricacies of the Kendrick Lamar and Drake battle, or the many moving parts of the Young Thug and YSL RICO case. Beyond engaging and breaking news coverage, Gabriel makes the most out of his concert obsessions, reviewing and recapping festivals like Rolling Loud Miami and Camp Flog Gnaw. He’s also developed a strong editorial voice through album reviews, think-pieces, and interviews with some of the genre’s brightest upstarts and most enduring obscured gems like Homeboy Sandman, Bktherula, Bas, and Devin Malik.